Skip to Main Content

Reference Checks

Reference checks should be initiated for all final candidates, prior to recommending a candidate for a position.

Guide to Checking References

Reference checks should be initiated for all final candidates prior to recommending a candidate for the position. Obtain several professional references for each candidate under serious consideration. Personal references usually do not provide objective information.

Always contact the employee's current or most recent employer. If a candidate prefers that their direct supervisor not be contacted, attempt to contact Human Resources or request that they provide someone else who works for the company or a customer who is willing to provide a reference. If requested, agree not to check current references unless they are the final candidate.

Although not required, written consent is recommended to check references.

Contacting Someone Not Listed as a Reference

The signed application gives Miami University permission to conduct a background review. If you know someone who worked with the candidate in the past and could provide a reliable reference, you may contact them as a reference. However, as a courtesy, you should inform the candidate that you intend to contact the person.

Liability for References

Employers that provide truthful information pertaining to an employee's job performance are not liable.

If an employer provides information that they know is false, with the intent to mislead the prospective employer, they may be found liable.

An employer may also be found liable if the information provided is found to be discriminatory.

You cannot ensure that references give correct information; however, if a claim of "negligent hiring" arose and you conducted a thorough reference check, the claim could likely be moved to the reference that knowingly gave you the incorrect information in your reference check.

Sharing Reference Check Information

Share reference check information only with individuals that are part of the search committee. Reference information, however, is public record and must be maintained in the search file.

Please see the Records and Retention manual for guidance on retention of files.

Reference Checks on Internal Candidates

A personnel file is a good source of information for an internal candidate. Interviewing committees should consider reviewing the employee file as an essential step in the hiring process. Contact HR to set up a time to view an internal candidate's personnel file by calling 513-529-3131.

You may contact the internal candidate's current supervisor. As a courtesy, you should inform the candidate that you would like to speak to his/her current supervisor. If the candidate expresses concern regarding you contacting the current supervisor, discuss options of other possible references that can speak to his/her performance. (Perhaps a co-worker or contact in another office on campus that the candidate works with regularly.)

Approach to Contacting References

It is preferable that you contact references by phone. Writing to the reference often results in little information or no response and does not provide an opportunity for clarification or additional information.

References should be contacted by a member of the Search Committee or Human Resources. If contact is to be made by Human Resources, please email the following information to an HR Generalist in the Employment, Compensation and Technology area:

  • Set of questions to be asked
  • List of candidates and associated references
  • Name of the person to whom the reference checks should be returned

Our Mission

Working alongside the various departments and units within Miami University, we strive to recruit, cultivate, acknowledge, and involve a diverse pool of talent to fulfill their goals and the overarching goals of the institution.