Search for Publications, Reports, and Presentations
Long-Term Care Facilities
• Quality Assurance
• Long-Term Care Policy and Financing
• Program Evaluation
The Effects of Medicaid Payment and Payment-to-Cost Ratio on Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Ratings
Medicaid is the largest payer of nursing home (NH) care in the United States, yet Medicaid payments are not required to cover the full cost of care.
•
Long-Term Care Facilities
• Quality Assurance
• Long-Term Care Policy and Financing
• Program Evaluation
The Effects of Medicaid Payment and Payment-to-Cost Ratio on Nursing Home Five-Star Quality Ratings
•
Objectives
Medicaid is the largest payer of nursing home (NH) care in the United States, yet Medicaid payments are not required to cover the full cost of care. Little is known about the relationship between Medicaid payment adequacy and Care Compare's star ratings. This study examined the association between Medicaid payment rate and whether Medicaid payment covered the cost of care and NH 5-star ratings.
Design
Cross-sectional study using facility-level national data.
Setting and Participants
The analytic sample included 9473 freestanding NHs across 44 states in 2019.
Methods
Facility-level Medicaid payment rates were collected from states and matched with Medicaid-related costs to calculate Medicaid payment-to-cost ratios. These measures were linked to Care Compare 5-star ratings (overall, health inspection, quality measures, total staffing) and facility/resident characteristics. Multivariate regressions with state fixed effects and bivariate analysis assessed the relationship between Medicaid payments and Medicaid payment-to-cost ratios and 5-star ratings.
Results
Bivariate and regression findings indicate that higher Medicaid payment rates were associated with increased probability of NHs receiving 4- or 5-star ratings for the overall, health inspection, and staffing domains. Bivariate statistics found that higher Medicaid payment-to-cost ratios were associated with lower star ratings, but regression analysis found that Medicaid payment-to-cost ratios close to or exceeding 1.0 had a high probability of receiving 4 or 5 stars on the overall and health inspection star ratings. Neither Medicaid payment measure showed a consistent relationship with the quality measure rating.
Conclusions and Implications
Medicaid payment levels and payment-to-cost ratios were associated with Care Compare's 5-star ratings. Findings suggest that inadequate Medicaid payment rates undermine NH quality and that nursing homes need to subsidize Medicaid losses with profits from other sources. Policymakers should consider the adequacy of Medicaid payment when seeking to improve quality of care for long-stay residents, as payment policy remains a critical lever for strengthening NH performance.
Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jamda.2025.106042